provide a key to establishing a link between staining/stain repellency, the chemical nature of the substrate (coating), and
the chemical nature of the staining agents.
HSP values can be estimated25 from surface energy data but the calculations are
estimates at best, especially given the limited number of solvents used in this study.
The surface energy analysis only determines the dispersive (Van der Waals) surface energy contribution and the total polar
contribution (which in HSP is split into
hydrogen bonding and polar components).
Additionally, neither this study nor HSP adequately describes acid-base contributions.
This study, while not being comprehensive of all factors potentially involved (e.g.,
HSP, contact angle, surface energy, acid-base), does show convincingly the lack of
correlation between contact angle and stain
repellency. The problem is more complex
and should be investigated further.
This work shows that while determina-
tion of contact angle and surface energy is
suitable for some applications like adhesive
bonding (a long term or permanent effect),
it is not appropriate as a predictive tool for
determining stain repellency in coatings.
As a result of the comprehensive study
we were able to develop a new stain re-
pellent additive for interior architectural
coatings that improves stain repellency
to household chemicals in most paints at
concentrations ranging from 1.0 to 3.0%.
This product is SILRES® BS 6500 A, for
more information contact WACKER.
Future Work
Several other components of surface
properties could be investigated to determine if they have any impact upon stain
repellency and correlating other surface
measurements to stain repellency.
Table 13: Water contact angle correlation coefficient data
Correlation Calculation Property
(n = 171 samples)
Correlation Coefficient
Water contact angle 1.00
Dispersive surface free energy -0.16
Polar surface free energy -0.89
Total surface free energy -0.90
Dodecane contact angle 0.12
(n = 158 samples) 0.58
Diiodomethane contact angle 0.55
(n = 13 samples) 0.63