S
p
ec
i
a
l
Re
p
ort
S
IT
E
SE
L
E
C
TI
ON
54 DC VELOCITY JANUARY 2017 www.dcvelocity.com
4. UNCERTAINTY IN INTERNATIONAL TRADE
It’s not just local or national concerns that are altering how
companies make warehouse site-selection decisions. Export
opportunities and trade agreements are also of growing
importance to our clients. But there seems to be growing
resistance in some regions toward free-trade agreements,
as demonstrated by “Brexit”—the United Kingdom’s
planned departure from the European Union (EU)—and
opposition to the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) in the
United States.
In general, we believe that it will take years for the details
of Brexit to take shape, and to understand its resulting
pivotal site-selection variable here in the U.S.—will have to
be expanded and better funded by U.K. policymakers.
It is likely that Brexit will also have the effect of slowing
the pace of negotiations for the Transatlantic Trade and
Investment Partnership (TTIP) agreement between the
United States and the EU. That trade pact would create the
world’s largest free-trade zone—dwarfing even the North
American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA). Today, the
U.S. and the EU together account for one-half of global
gross domestic product (GDP) and one-third of all world
trade. New DC investments related to TTIP in Europe
as well as in the environs of U.S. East Coast ports like
New York/New Jersey; Charleston, S.C.; and Savannah,
Ga., are also likely to stall given the slowed pace of TTIP
negotiations.
The Trans-Pacific Partnership—which would have connected the U.S. with 12 countries accounting for another 40
percent of global GDP—has been soundly rejected by the
incoming Trump administration. Donald Trump’s populist position on free trade overall is creating apprehension
within the U.S. supply chain and is raising questions as to
what trade and tariff challenges shippers will be facing—
factors sure to influence location decisions about new DCs.
Meanwhile, Canadian export opportunities and trade
pacts are gaining the attention of the U.S.
logistics industry. Canada has free-trade
agreements with 40 countries, while the U.S.
has only 20. Popular support for free trade
with Japan and China has historically been
much higher in Canada than in the U.S. Also,
Canada now has its own free-trade accord
with the EU, the Comprehensive Economic
and Trade Agreement (CETA) signed by
Prime Minister Trudeau in October 2016. As
a result, more U.S. companies are eyeing DC
options in places like eastern Ontario to take
advantage of Canada’s global trade accords as
well as to serve cross-border markets in the
vast Northeast megalopolis region stretching
from Boston to Baltimore.
These four trends clearly show that warehousing has been at the crux of many changes
in the past few years: new technologies, new
customer demands, and new talent requirements. Meanwhile, a sluggish economy and
an uncertain future have company executives
keeping a close watch on costs. To navigate
these changing times, warehouses and distribution centers will need to transform their
operations to meet new economic realities
while continuing to monitor costs like never
before.
Editor’s note: John H. Boyd is a principal with
the location consultants The Boyd Co. Inc.
Distribution Warehouse (Region) Total Annual Operating Costs (US$)
Meadowlands/Northern New Jersey $21,322,480
Cranbury/Central New Jersey $20,663,653
Stoughton/Southeastern Massachusetts $20,154,292
Bridgeport/Southern New Jersey $19,787,526
Springfield/Central Massachusetts $19,747,214
Danbury/Southern Connecticut $19,165,711
Newburgh/Hudson Valley, New York $18,699,489
Windsor/Northern Connecticut $18,561,154
Lehigh Valley, Pennsylvania $18,484,896
Camp Hill/Central Pennsylvania $18,473,104
Syracuse/Upstate New York $18,462,136
Schenectady/Upstate New York $18,400,406
Pittsburgh/Western Pennsylvania $18,131,187
York/Southeastern Pennsylvania $18,024,334
Concord/Southern New Hampshire $17,933,749
Hagerstown/Western Maryland $17,318,301
Dover/Central Delaware $16,963,894
Eastern Ontario (Canada) $13,412,191
SOURCE: BIZCOSTS, A REGISTERED TRADEMARK OF THE BOYD CO. INC. LOCATION CONSULTANTS, 2016
ANNUAL COSTS ARE BASED ON A 500,000-SQUARE-FOOT DISTRIBUTION CENTER EMPLOYING 250
WORKERS SERVING THE NORTHEAST UNITED STATES AND EASTERN CANADA CONSUMER MARKETS.
EXHIBIT 1
Total annual geographically variable
operating-cost ranking