DC Velocity - July 2009

the ancient art of
military logistics

Re: “mission possible,” June 2009

Great article about the transition efforts under way in Iraq. DC VELOCITY has done an excellent job updating readers on the efforts of our military forces around the world. Since “logistics” was born out of ancient military campaigns, it is only natural that the magazine continue to feature these types of articles. I also enjoyed the fact that the logistician was a female.

Scott Mc Williams, OHL

well, duh!

Re: “the fatal flaw in ERP,” Tech Watch, March 2009

Of course this solution [Mark Payne’s formula for calculating how much a company must produce to meet demand] is right. Inventory is what is supposed to be variable along with demand. In the short term, production (supply) cannot be variable.

Andrew De Witt, Tosca Ltd.

letters to the editor

Letters should be written exclusively to DC VELOCITY and may contain thoughts, comments, suggestions and criticisms of both DC VELOCITY and developments in the supply chain field. They should not exceed 200 words and may be edited for clarity. The decision to publish or not to publish is solely at the discretion of the editor.

All letters must include the author’s daytime phone number. Send submissions to: “To the Editor,” DC VELOCITY, 500 East Washington St., Suite 4, N. Attleboro, MA 02760 or to peter@dcvelocity.com with “To the Editor” in the subject line.

acrossthedock

Re: “cell-ing the transition,” June 2009

Mark B. Solomon’s otherwise excellent article on hydrogen fuel cells for lift trucks included an estimate by a battery-charger developer that a fuel cell-powered lift truck uses three times more energy than a truck using a battery. This statement is meaningless without specifying both how the hydrogen is produced and how the electricity used to charge batteries is being generated.

According to an Argonne National Laboratory study published in 2008 (Full Fuel-Cycle Comparison of Forklift Propulsion Systems), a fuel cell forklift using hydrogen produced on site from natural gas—a technology that is commercially available from Nuvera and others—uses less energy than a battery-powered forklift when recharged with standard U.S. grid electricity, on a national average basis.

The Argonne National Laboratory report is available, at no cost, through the Department of Energy’s Office of Scientific & Technical Information’s Web site: http://www.osti.gov/bridge.